Skip to main content

Toulmin Method and Hailey vs. Selena

In the textbook Communicating Online the Toulmin method “describes several key elements of an argument (…) the claim and the reasons and evidence (also called data) offered to support the claim.” (Julia Green) page 283. This is the Toulmin method in it’s simplest terms. This method is useful to understand others arguments and your own. It helps you to look at the logic of the argument. 

Julia Green 
A great example of the Toulmin method is the team Hailey vs. Selena drama. Tik Tokers are posing their arguments using claim, reasoning and evidence to portray the other one in a negative light. 
Tik Tok @kylazingaround
Claim: 
Hailey is making fun of Selena Gomez’s body.
Evidence: 
Around that time Hailey Bieber posted a video saying “I’m not saying she deserved it but I’m saying gods timing is always right.” (Bieber) Selena commented on the video “she doesn’t let these things get her down.” (Gomez). Hailey took the video down
Reasoning: 
The video was posted right after the shaming comments. When Hailey deleted the video it was confirmation that the shade was directed at Selena. 

Claim: 
Selena is overthinking and overreacting.
Evidence: 
Hailey commented on her own video “I never comment on this type of thing but we were just having a girls night and did a random Tik Tok sound for fun. It’s not directed at anyone.” (Bieber).
Reasoning: 
The video was very vague and not directed at anyone. Selena and Hailey have a history of beef. Selena took things out of context and was dragging up old drama from years ago. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Social Media: Good or Bad?

       As a society we are faced with pressing questions involving social media, and what to do with our impending generations. It is important to identify the good things social media does while also acknowledging the drawbacks. I do believe that with each social media platform comes it’s own set of pros and cons. This is because each platform appeals to different facets of our lives. Instagram is where we romanticize our own lives and post a highlight reel (con) where we keep our friends informed on major events happening in our lives (pro). TikTok can be an endless black hole where all of our time disappears (con), but you can learn new dances, recipes and add travel destinations to your bucket list (pro).      A large topic under discussion is if mental health promotion lies on the shoulders of the platform. I argue that this is not the platforms problem. While social media does create mental health issues it is up to the consumer to seek out menta...
Post a Comment
Read more

Twitter Feuds

  I chose a  Twitter feud between Chris Brown and Jenny Johnson. It is a famous incident that occurred in 2012. Here's a brief overview of what happened: Jenny Johnson, a writer and comedian, had been a vocal critic of Chris Brown for years due to his history of domestic violence. In November 2012, Johnson tweeted a sarcastic comment about Brown's latest tattoo, which appeared to be a depiction of a battered woman's face. Brown responded with a series of vulgar and aggressive tweets directed at Johnson, including insults and threats of violence. Johnson continued to engage with Brown, leading to a back-and-forth exchange that lasted several hours. The incident garnered widespread media attention and sparked a larger conversation about domestic violence and the way that celebrities are held accountable for their actions. It also raised questions about the role of social media in public discourse and the responsibility of public figures to engage with their critics in a respe...
Post a Comment
Read more